Monday, 25 September 2017

Shape Mapping Paper and Phononic Band Gaps releasend

I'm happy to have two new papers published the last week.

The one is my shape mapping approach, a general description:

Wein, F. & Stingl, M. A combined parametric shape optimization and ersatz material approach. Struct Multidisc Optim (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-017-1812-3

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00158-017-1812-3

In the second article I present the 2D phononic band gaps. My colleague Max Wormser did the interpretation for 3D, printed the structure by electron beam melting with titanium and performed measurements:

Wormser, M.; Wein, F.; Stingl, M.; Körner, C. Design and Additive Manufacturing of 3D Phononic Band Gap Structures Based on Gradient Based Optimization. Materials 2017, 10, 1125.

http://www.mdpi.com/1996-1944/10/10/1125

Edit: The statistics of this article are amazing (for my standards)! 60+ downloads in the first week. Might it be the world record breaking phononic band gap optimization or the printing and measuring of a 3D sample by Max.

Sunday, 11 June 2017

WCSMO12 is over

WCSMO 12 link is just over.

After the previous once (for me) in Lisbon, Orlando and Sydney, Braunschweig sounds unexcitedly. It was just a 4 hours drive with the car. We were a total of 8 people with 7 from Michael Singl's group.

However, it turned out to be a quite nice and successful conference. To my personal impression the quality of the talks was better than in Sydney. There were about 550 people with up to 7 parallel sessions. Session hopping done very much but also possible due to close rooms and good time management of the chairs. However the sessions were in my eyes also organized in a way that you need session hopping. Sometimes the "big" names were in rooms to small for them.

There was for my interest to much overlapping of parallel tasks I was interested. E.g. Niels Aaage's and Rasmus' talk parallel to my own session. I wish there were less parallel sessions but I don't known how to achieve this, maybe minisymposia would help.

I was not that happy about the poster session. It was parallel to three session and as I had my talk there I could only be at the poster session in the break before. The poster session was nicely prominent in Orlando but also in Sydney I was not that happy with the poster session. I personally often feel that posters are often treated as less valuable whereas I indeed often prefer them against talks.

Beside this the organization was quite well done. Long breaks with enough time for talking, cake and beverages all the time. The crew was excellent! The welcome reception was the best I ever had: Good food, a lot to drink and a lot of space and room to talk and meet. Wetter was very good, we could open the windows for fresh air most of the time.

Compared to ECCOMAS 2016 in Crete there was not really something big new. The overhang constraints from Matthijs Langelaar evolved. The laminate interpretations from Ole's group based on Olivier Pantz' ideas was nice, something like my old streamline stuff done right and rigorous :) However I personal think, it needs to become 3D and when the issues there are solved, I'll be very impressed! The talk I liked most was actually Dan's the state-of-the-art talk. I could not attend Kurt Maute's talk, but my colleagues were quite impressed.

Saturday, 10 June 2017

Phononic Band Gaps up to relative 8!

This is my presentation of "Parametric Shape Optimization of Lattice Structures for Phononic Band Gaps" I gave at WCSMO-12 June 2017 in Braunschweig.



I'm quite proud of my phononic band gaps up to relative 8 and normalized 1.6.

I already presented the idea at ECCOMAS 2016 in Crete but there I made the embarrassing mistake of not enforcing square symmetry. However this is a non that uncommon mistake I meanwhile learned. Also my results are much better now.

Friday, 23 October 2015

WCSMO-11 is over

Some time passed since the last WCSMO-11 which was held in Sydney in June 2015. Still I know of no regular conference which comes any close to the World Congress of Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization. The first OPTi in 2014 held in Kos came close but I see no hint that OPTi will be continued.

To my opinion people were (in the beginning) not happy to travel as far as Australia for a conference - something like the place with the furthest traveling distance for almost everyone I meet at conferences. 

And indeed I missed some participants from the US and Europe where on the other side many speakers came from China. The total number of participant also was a little below the previous numbers. 

I personally was disappointed by the average quality of the presentations. The two worst presentations I attended were from the US and Europe and I had the impression that both speakers did not even understand / could handle the SIMP method at the level of the 99 lines code. But there were more disappointing talks. To my personal opinion there are not too much groups worldwide driving topology optimization further with solid research while there are still plenty of challenging issues and problems, which can be solved by topology optimization. I cannot compare this against the previous WCSMO’s due to too many parallel sessions and I regularly missed some important talks. 

So maybe it would be a good idea to reduce the number of presentations and increase the average quality for the WCSMO but concurrently introduce regional conferences where PhD students have the opportunity to present their works and more importantly can come into contact to their regional experts, especially when they don’t stem from one of the established groups.

My highlight of the WCSMO was the high-performance optimization done at the DTU and I very much acknowledge that they contribute the PETSc base implementation with a parallel linear elasticity, MMA, density filter and PDE filter. More on that in a separate blog post. 

To summarize, the WCSMO-11 2015 in Sydney was again not only a good conference but almost the only conference (to my knowledge) for structural optimization. It was well organized; it was pretty cool to have a conference banquet at “Hogwarts” (the great hall of the University of Sydney). I personally also enjoyed Sydney and my short trip to the Blue Mountains.

What I really missed was that there was no possibility to just sit (and talk) when I did not want to attend a presentation. There was nothing like a lobby or close cafeteria. Especially when it was cold and raining and one could not go outside.

Monday, 30 June 2014

Interpretation of Material Design by an Streamline Approach

At OPT-I 2014, Kos, Greece, 4-6 June 2014, www.opti2014.org I gave the following talk:



It demonstrates, how a material design result of oriented anisotropic structures (here crosses) can be interpreted.


We are still in the early phase, e.g. removing the blind line segments and going to 3D.

Sunday, 29 December 2013

Topology optimization of saturated flows

In 2013 I spent most of my time for a topology optimization project for Procter & Gamble. Technically it we perform transient multi-material optimization for the nonlinear Richards equation which models unsaturated flow. The product behind is a Pampers diaper. The first phase of the project is successfully finished. It was quite hard and computationally and numerically the most complicated and expensive problem I had to deal with up to now.

During summer slump when there is nothing else to report in the local newspaper, we even had two interviews. Well, I doubt this is the career boost a colleague sees in it - and the article is really written for the broad public by non-technicals journalists.

Sorry, all in German.

14. August 2013, Nuerberger Zeitung
Das High-Tech-Produkt für den trockenen Babypopo

15. August 2013, Nordbayrische Nachrichten
Gutes für den Baby-Po: Erlanger Forscher suchen nach der Super-Windel

Here the announcement of the Cluster of Excellence Advanced Materials
http://blogs.fau.de/news/2013/07/30/gutes-fur-den-baby-popo/


Friday, 4 October 2013

Talk on Local Optimal Polarization

I'm just back from the piezo-workshop 2013, correctly, the 9th Int. Workshop on Direct and Inverse Problems in Piezoelectricity in Weimar, organized by Prof. Tom Lahmer, a former colleague.

On the workshop 2012 and at WCSMO-10 I presented piezoelectric Free Material Optimization (FMO), however, this makes not that much sense for piezoelectricity, as weak material is the generally best and the optimum is just controlled by the lower bound. For elasticity, where stiff material is in general good, this is a complete different story.

Doing orientational optimization, which has the physical interpretation of local polarization, the problem makes much sense and indeed has potential.



Two further examples I want to solve are dynamic problems (can the resonance frequency be moved by polarization, I guess so but it might be a small effect) and a solid auxetic (negative Poisson's ratio) device, what would be really impressing if this is possible.

Wednesday, 29 May 2013

WCSMO-10 is over

WCSMO-10 is over, and again I realized, that the WCSMO is by far the most interesting conference for me. The whole numerical topology optmization community was there and I enjoyed it very much. I have the impression that I meanwhile know a lot of the important people (at least a little :)).


I held a talk on piezoelectric free material optimization, similar to what I talked about on the last Workshop on Direct and Inverse Problems in Piezoelectricity, but this time not starting with the music of Jean Michel Jarre :)

People liked our tensor stiffness visualization, maybe I should put the Python code online ...

I also had a poster at the poster session about self-penalization. The content is from a former talk and can be also found in my thesis. My impression is, that private and direct communication/ discussion is best for the topic. The poster can also be downloaded.




This time Jamie Guest was almost omnipresent with a very large group. He appeared on 13 talks as (co-)author compared to 8 talks (co-)authored by Ole Sigmund. Well, numbers are one thing but it's impressive.

My favorite talk was by Alexander Verbart from the group of Fred van Keulen; A new approach for stress-based topology optimization: internal stress penalization. I did a little on stress optimization (e.g. piezoelectric stress optimization) but for me there are two open problems: have not grayness to confirm to the constraints and the miracle of the min vol problem which would be best for rho = rho_min. The idea of Alexander has neither stress penalization nor globalization parameters, subregions or anything else. The approach would allow gray material to confirm with the stresses but with some luck the optimizer won't find this solution. I'll have to give it a try.



Thursday, 5 April 2012

The new TopOpt App from DTU

Ole Sigmund's DTU topology optimization team released their TopOpt App for iOS, Android and Web. This is pretty cool stuff. It allows to play with any variant of a compliance problem. With respect to the original TopOpt web application it is interactive and as such it is as interactive as our our iTop web application (eamc080.eam.uni-erlangen.de/iTop. IMHO, the TopOpt app suits better a tablet than a smartphone/ iPod, but on a tablet it is really interactive, and it is real fun to play with it. I let my 5 years old daughter play with the TopOpt app what would not work with iTop.

With the TopOpt app being an off-line app, I started to show almost any person (I have a beer with and who is not escaping fast enough) what this topology optimization stuff is all about on my iPod.

From the technical point of view I'm impressed by the performance. It is clear, that despite their user experience, the ARM processing power is significant slower than our iTop Xenon CPU. I would have guessed that the performance wouldn't be sufficient and I would have been wrong! I wonder about the direct solver and the Heaviside filter parameters.

So what it the difference to iTop? The TopOpt app is self-explaining while iTop deserves explanation (especially as we still did not write any documentation). But using iTop as a demonstrator tool it allows to explain what is behind
  • penalization,
  • regularization.
  • choice of optimizer,
  • the phenomenon of self-penalization,
  • start designs/ local optima.
I'm pretty sure the force inverter problem will be soon integrated into the TopOpt app, while interactive material design via inverse homogenization might be a unique feature of iTop for a longer time.

Congratulations, Niels, Morten and Casper! :)

Monday, 16 January 2012

Thesis published

Finished! :)

On the 19th of December 2011 I had the defence of my thesis (Dr. Ing.).



I published my thesis online. You can access it at UB Erlangen-Nuermberg.

The thesis

Topology Optimization of Smart Piezoelectric Transducers

has three main topics:
  • topology optimization of a piezoelectric loupspeaker
  • topology optimization of a piezoelectric cantilevered energy harvester
  • self-penalization in topology optimization

Thank's a lot to my colleagues for the great hat!! :)

I will continue as PostDoc at my current position, working for Prof. Stingl at the chair of applied mathematics from Prof. Leugering.

Monday, 2 January 2012

Interactive Self-Penalization

I added mechanism design to our iTop tool, see also my last post. This allows to play with the force inverter problem. Volume constraint bounds can be switched, regularization can be disabled by setting "reg. value" to one. It makes sense to play with "start optimization from current design". Local solutions are really a problem. Sometimes it helps to play with the physical lower bound (rho^p) and penalization values.

Clearly, the results are not necessarily more "desirable" than the volume constraint results. But IMHO this is not the point. Here not the practical relevance of the result is interesting but the strong self-penalizing effect.

BTW, I finished my PhD! :) More to write about this next week when I officially publish my thesis (online).

Thursday, 8 December 2011

iTop - interactive topology optimization

Our work group developed an interactive topology optimization web client.

eamc080.eam.uni-erlangen.de/iTop


This is very similar to topopt from Ole Sigmund's group. While topopt demonstrates the possibilities of topology optimization (including mechanism design and 3D compliance), we somehow have a more educational focus.

With out interactive topology optimization (iTop) you can play with the regularization and optimizer. Furthermore we include 2D material design where e.g. auxetic material (negative Poisson's ratio) can be designed.

A good example is SNOPT as optimizer with slope constraints as regularization. Both are rather slow for compliance problems but for very challenging material design problems this might be the only possible choice.

What I often show is the non-convex property of penalized compliance. Enable "start optimization from current design" and "restart new optimization on parameter change".
For sufficient penalization, moving the force point might result in a clearly poor local solution. Now taking away the penalization (switch to 1) and activate it again (e.g. 3) the "global optimal" solution is found.

For several parameter sets optimization might fail. By this we want to demonstrate, that optimization is not a black-box problem!

The documentation and all the references are still missing, therefore we do not link to iTop officially from our chair's web page. We hope we can provide some documentation soon.

While being based on our optimization software, iTop is a demonstrator tool only. This is not necessarily the kind of problems we solve in our academic work. iTop contains just a small selection of our tools.

Enjoy and ask if you have any questions.

eamc080.eam.uni-erlangen.de/iTop

Friday, 28 October 2011

Self-Penalization in Topology Optimization

I gave a talk at EUROMECH 522 in Erlangen on the 10th of October 2011.

It appears that most people from the audience did not understand what I wanted to say - so clearly a bad presentation of mine! :(

However, discussions during the conference after the presentation helped me point out the missing items and emphasis in my presentation.

Therefore I provide here a variant of the talk with some additional slides. If you are interested in the subject I'll be very happy to discuss it with you! :)

The key point is, that I do not present anything like a method or something big. I just want to motivate to have a slightly different point of view on our daily topology optimization problems. (But to be honest, to my humble personal opinion this off the mainstream look on topology optimization might result in important insights :))


Wednesday, 13 July 2011

Thesis Submitted

I finally submitted my thesis! :) I guess the defense will be in September or October. Afterwards I will publish my thesis online for free download. The title is "Topology Optimization of Smart Piezoelectric Transducers"

It basically consists of three parts:

* Topology optimization of piezoelectric actors, with single-frequency loudspeakers in mind.
* Topology optimization of piezoelectric cantilever type energy harvesters
* Self-penalization in topology optimization

For the harvester I applied piezoelectric dynamic stress constraints, which were actually easier to handle than in elasticity as I do right now :)

The self-penalization stuff goes much further than covered in the piezoelectric self-penalization paper.

The introductory stuff became quite extensive. When the thesis is published my plan is to compile all the linear elasticity stuff to an "Introduction to ersatz material topology optimization in linear elasticity", which might serve as what the title suggests. :) The idea is to publish it as technical report and provide free access to it.

I'm happy that writing the thesis is over! My plans for the future are not settled but it looks like that I stay for some more time in academia. ;)

Saturday, 26 February 2011

EUROMECH522 and Piezo-Workshop 2011

I'll be at the 7th International Workshop on Direct and Inverse Problems in Piezoelectricit, October 4th - 7th, in Oer-Erkenschwick, Germany. It is a very small town but Moondog lived there for some years. I was at the 5th and 6th Piezo Workshop. It is a small event in a very comfortable atmosphere with very easy exchange to other people. I learned a lot about piezoelectric material there.

Following is the EUROMECH522 "Recent Trends in Optimisation for Computational Solid Mechanics" October 10th-13th in Erlangen. It is an colloquium with invited participants only (as far as I understand). I hope they accept my abstract. I want to talk about self-penalization in topology optimization. I have some new results/observations in addition to the paper On the effect of self-penalization of piezoelectric composites in topology optimization. The dynamic stuff is still an open issue and I have not explored some ideas I had. In case I'll get accepted to EUROMECH522, I'm quite curious about it as I haven not been on such an colloquium before. I hope many Danish topology optimizers come, they are the reference.

For private reasons I won't come to WCSMO-9 :( That is sad as WCSMO-8 was the most important conference for me up to now.

Thursday, 4 November 2010

Stress Constraints

I started to work with stress constraints. It's pretty interesting and up to now more stuff seems unclear to me that being clarified.

I read a bunch of papers, but need to read the original Duysinx and Bendsoe; Topology optimization of continuum structures with local stress constraints; 1998 paper again (maybe there are the answers to my questions hidden :)). Our results are in good agreement with the standard solutions, so our approach seems to work. However, the results of Le; Stress-based topology optimization for continua; 2010 are really extraordinary good, unmatched by any other publication I read and far better that our results.

I still wonder, why

min vol
s.th. stress constraint

works. At least for qp-regularization (Bruggi; On an alternative approach to stress constraints relaxation in topology optimization; 2008) rho_min should be the global optimum. But the results are all similar to the compliance solution. I cannot imagine, that the regularization just hides this global optimum as we use a second order optimizer ... well, I hope I'll find out.

The next thing is, that beside Le, all (of what I read up to now) published results show some grayness embedded in full material. What happens if we have to map to manufacturable black and white topologies? I have not found any discussion of this grayness yet.

Wednesday, 13 October 2010

Paper on Piezoelectric Self-Penalization Published

Our second paper is published (online):

F. Wein, M. Kaltenbacher, B. Kaltenbacher, G. Leugering, E. Baensch and F. Schury; On the effect of self-penalization of piezoelectric composites in topology optimization; Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization; DOI: 10.1007/s00158-010-0570-2

springerlink

It covers the effect of self-penalization of many piezoelectric topology optimization problems. That means that no penalization, volume constraint and regularization is applied to gain often mesh independent black and white solutions. It's not a method we describe but a phenomenon, so to report when it does not work is part of the job.
I guess we implemented almost all relevant piezoelectric objective functions and to compare them based on the same model is IMHO also of interest. The objective functions are mean transduction, displacement, sound power, electric potential, electric energy, energy conversion and electric power.

We give an explanation based on the piezoelectric model: stiffness, electrostatic and piezoelectric coupling. More density is bad with respect to stiffness but good for the other fields, opposite for less density. That means that there is balance of the effects and when this balance is outside the feasible design set (0,1], there is no greyness.

Self-penalization has been, to my knowledge, first reported by Ole Sigmund and Jakob S. Jensen 2003 with (elastic) wave guiding. It also appears in other, especially non-elastic problems but has never been investigated. Meanwhile I almost belief that probably most non-compliance problems show some form of self-penalization. I hope I can find a general explanation as this might eventually lead to new method in topology optimization. :) I have at least one idea on how to proceed ... Let's see when I find the time and if I have success.

P.S.: It seems that the term "self-penalization" has not been used before in the context of topology optimization (I actually don't want to know what google finds for self-penalization in other contexts :) ) but I learned the expression from Ole Sigmund, so he deserves the credits.

Wednesday, 6 October 2010

Mean Transduction

In 1999, Silva et al. introduced in

Silva, Nishiwaki, Kikuchi; Design of piezocomposite materials and piezoelectric transducers using topology optimization—Part II; Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering; 1999


the objective function mean transduction. It describes the piezoelectric coupling, and it is quite intuitive to maximize that coupling. The mean transduction was applied quite often by Silva. To my knowledge there are no recent publications, where it is used, but I might be wrong.

I don't use the function but as I started 4 years ago with it, it is still in my mind and somehow I still try to actually understand it properly.

I make currently good progress in writing my thesis and just work on a section about mean transduction. I finally found the link between mean transduction and classical adjoint based sensitivy analysis - which clearly helps in understanding the nature of the mean transduction. Just, I don't know if this is of interest, as I don't know, if the mean transduction is used any more. For sensor applications, maximizing the electric power as done by Cory Rupp is IMHO more practical - and for actor applications the physics might be necessary, e.g. acoustic formulations to prevent acoustic short circuits as I have shown.

This piezo stuff is really heavy (optimization) stuff :)

Sunday, 30 May 2010

Applet visualizing square plate vibrations

I found this very cool applet from Paul Falstad. There are many more technical applets on his homepage.

The applet allows to interactively play with the structural resonance modes of an elastic plate. I also like the transient simulation when the plate is "pinged" by the mouse.

Von Pizeo Blog

Paul made cool applets for several physical problems, worth to have look :)

Sunday, 23 May 2010

Acoustic near field topology optimization

Here I share my talk I gave on ECCM 2010. It presents acoustic near field optimization. Last year, at WCSMO-8 I compared acoustic topology optimization where the acoustic field was assumed to be far field/ plane wave type/ constant acoustic impedance at the structure itself (so no acoustic is calculated) and at the boundary of by acoustic domain. Now I did the step further and optimize the acoustic power directly w/o any assumption. Thanks to Michael Stingl who helped with some very useful comments! It turned out, that the same objective function had already been used in Jensen and Sigmund; Topology optimization of photonic crystal structures: a high-bandwidth low-loss T-junction waveguide; 2005. It was disappointing that it had (for other physics) already been done - but it would have been really bad if I had not found it and claimed it as a own result.

For my numerical examples the optimal results where quite close to the acoustic far field optimization. This was quite surprising but before I could for lower frequencies not guarantee any physical validity. So it was definitely worth it.